AN EXAMINATION OF THE CHALLENGES FACING THE NIGERIAN CRIMINAL JUSTICE SECTOR: THE HOLDING CHARGE PRACTICE
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Department of Public and International Law, Nasarawa State University Keffi
DOI
Abstract
The practice of Holding Charge which is a form of pre-trial detention has been viewed as one of the major legal constraints to proper and swift administration of Criminal Justice in Nigeria and has remained unabated despite the apparent opposition against such practice in advanced legal systems like England and United States of America. This research work is an exposition of the said practice, making a case for either its repeal or resort for possible alternatives to the practice by making a comparative analysis of municipal, regional and international instruments, case law and statutes on the practice of holding charge (pre-trial detention) as well as analyzing the legality or otherwise of this phenomenon. Holding charge which involves the bringing of a suspect before an inferior court that lacks jurisdiction to try him or her for the primary purpose of securing a remand order, in order to look for a prima facie evidence in support of the allegation against the suspect and thereafter abandon him or her in prison under the pretext of awaiting trial, leaves one to wonder whether the presumption of innocence is tenable in Nigeria.
Also, the crisis of congestion in our prison is the result of the holding charge practice. It is trite that jurisdiction is the life-wire of any litigation whether civil or criminal and the base on which adjudication rest. It follows that there is obviously an anomaly in bringing a suspect for remand before a magistrate who has no power to impose penalty for the indictable offence allegedly committed by the suspect. Therefore, the practice by magistrate courts who lacked jurisdiction in indictable offence, but goes on to remand the suspect under holding charge have been considered unconstitutional, because it is a threat to the accused person‟s rights to personal liberty, dignity, and fair hearing granted by the 1999 constitution (as amended). However, some states laws have given magistrate court the impetus to continue with this harmful practice without regard to the provisions of the Nigerian Constitution. The new Administration of Criminal Justice Act (ACJA), 2015 equally did not abolish the practice. Consequently, this research work, in chapter one will take a look at the historical inception of holding charge; chapter two will focus on the meaning of the monster called holding charge, the reason for its adoption and the illegality. Chapter three will discuss on the rights of accused persons and how holding charge have thwarted its realization. Chapter four will examine the effect of holding charge in the criminal justice administration in Nigeria. Chapter five the last chapter contains observation and recommendation, mainly on abrogation of all the laws that gave magistrate courts power to remand suspects on indictable offences when they have no jurisdiction to entertain such cases.
Description
Keywords
Citation
BEING A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE POST GRADUATE SCHOOL, FACULTY OF LAW, NASARAWA STATE UNIVERSITY, KEFFI IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE AWARD OF THE DEGREE, MASTER OF LAWS (LL.M)
