VICTIM PARTICIPATION IN INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL PROCEDURE UNDER THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT (ICC)
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW FACULTY OF LAW NASARAWA STATE UNIVERSITY, KEFFI
DOI
Abstract
The Rome Statute of the ICC is notable for being the first international criminal statute to
include victim participation provisions in its procedures. These provisions span from the period
of investigations, where victims are permitted to make representations to the Prosecutor,
through pre-trial to the trial stages. This novel provision has been brought about by complaints
that poured out from experiences from the ad hoc tribunals for both Yugoslavia and Rwanda.
The complaints stemmed from the fact that the statutes setting up these ad hoc tribunals, like
their counterparts military tribunals for Nuremberg, etc, were focused on punishing the
perpetrators of serious crimes in the hopes of deterring future occurrences. The plights of
victims of such crimes were not much taken into account. The rise of human rights advocacy
had the effect of swaying debates towards the establishment of an independent international
criminal court, to mainstream victim participation into the operations of the ICC. The
applications of these provisions have raised many controversies, some of which go to the
legality of decisions of the ICC. This research also considered the outcome of the statutory
review/ amendment conference on the Rome Statute held in Kampala, Nairobi, in 2010.
Researchers view the many clashing decisions of Chambers of the Court on victim participation
as ominous. They cite delays, costs and re-victimization of victims, as some drawbacks to the
efficacy of the ICC. Worried about throwing away the baby with the bathwater, this study has
taken a foray into alternative justice delivery systems, like the truth and reconciliation
commissions and other traditional means of dispute resolution, to suggest that the ICC needs
not be bogged down by a deluge of victims seeking to participate in the procedures of the ICC.
Their interests and concerns may be sorted out locally, in the manner they are conversant with;
their reparations can more meaningfully be determined close to the theatres of their sufferings;
and closure can be better obtained by validation before their people that justice was done.
Besides, the lessons would be learnt by more of those in the localities, who may be tempted to
commit such crimes in the future. This research affirms that strengthening local laws and
infrastructure of justice delivery of member states, to enable them meet the requirements of
complementarity with the ICC, is necessary in making victim participation in the procedures
of the ICC meaningful and effective.
Description
Keywords
Citation
A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE SCHOOL OF POSTGRADUATE STUDIES, NASARAWA STATE UNIVERSITY, KEFFI, IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE AWARD OF A MASTERS OF LAW (LLM) DEGREE IN CONSTITUTIONAL AND HUMAN RIGHTS LAW
