APPRAISAL OF THE PRINCIPLES OF FAIR FIE A RING IN COURT MARTIAL PROCEEDINGS: THE ARMED FORCES OF NIGERIA IN PERSPECTIVE
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW FACULTY OF LAW NASARAWA STATE UNIVERSITY, KEFFI
DOI
Abstract
The research' work is anchored on "appraisal of the principles of fair hearing in the
Nigerian Armed Forces Court Martial trials". It involves an indebt examination of the
conceptual and application of fair hearing principles in court martial proceedings. The
research assesses the extent of the application of the principles offair hearing during pretrial,
trial and post-trial processes of accused personnel remanded for trial by court
martial. The work identifies commendable concerted and conscious efforts of the
Nigerian Military in adhering to the constitutional safeguards of fair hearing. It identifies
some safeguards peculiar to the military such as free accommodation, three square meals
a day, medical care, amongst others aimed at enhancing the fair trial of accused
personnel. In line with the acceptable notion of imperfection of man, the work identifies
some areas of short coming on application of principles of fair hearing in court martial.
The research examines the responsibility the Armed Forces Act places on the Attorney
General of the Federation to defence appeal cases emanating from court martial and
views this provision as a contravention of the right of the military to be defended by
counsel of its choice. This provision to the extent of its inconsistency with the Constitution
of the Federal Republic of Nigeria is considered void. The work identified the different
sitting arrangement of Judge Advocate and accused persons in the court martial of the
respective three Services and critically examined the merits and demerits therein. It
therefore recommends that the sitting position of the Judge Advocate with the members of
the court and next to the President adopted by the Nigerian Army and Air Force be
adopted by the three Services. Conversely, the sitting position of accused person at the
Bar with their counsel in the Nigerian Navy Court Martial should be adopted by the other
two Services. In Nigeria, appeal lies from Court Martial to the Court of Appeal whereas in
United Kingdom, appeal lies from Court Martial to Court Martial (Appeal) Court and
further appeal to their House of Lords (Nigerian Supreme Court equivalent). The Court
Martial (Appeal) Court has the status of a court of superior record consisting judges from
high courts, etc. This works notes that Armed Forces Disciplinary Appeal Committee
somehow similar to the British Court Martial (Appeal) Court but without status of court of
superior record was established in 1996 but was short lived. The work is of the view that if
the Armed Forces Disciplinary Appeal Committee had lasted, most of cases from court
martial lost at the Courts of Appeal would have been settled at the level of Armed Forces
Disciplinary Appeal Committee. Reintroduction of Armed Forces Disciplinary Appeal
Committee with modifications similar to British Court Martial (Appeal) Court with
military lawyers and judges periodically appointed as members is ideal. The work notes a
number of court martial trials going on at different commands in the three Services with
the tendency of distracting commanders and other personnel from concentrating on other
demanding tasks. This research therefore looks at the possibility of having a single
centralized court martial coordinated by Defence Headquarters or a centralized court
martial in each of the Services coordinated by the respective Services as suggested area of
further study.
Description
Keywords
Citation
A THESIS IN THE FACULTY OF LAW, SUBMITTED TO THE SCHOOL OF POST GRADUATE STUDIES, NASARAWA STATE UNIVERSITY, KEFFI IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE AWARD OF THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF LAWS
