JUDICIAL INTERPRETATION OF FREEDOM OF RELIGION IN NIGERIA AND UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW, FACULTY OF LAW, NASARAWA STATE UNIVERSITY, KEFFI.
DOI
Abstract
Judicial interpretation refers to a variety of ways that the judiciary uses to interpret the law,
especially constitutional and legislative enactments. Freedom of religion means the right of
individuals or groups, either in public or private, to propagate and manifest their religion or
belief in teaching, practice, worship, and observance, including the right to convert to another
religion and reconvert to the original religion without fear of molestation and obstruction.
Judicial interpretation of freedom of religion refers to the judges' role of interpreting the law-,
particularly legislative and constitutional enactments, in relation to the right of individual or
group to propagate and manifest his or her religious beliefs, privately or publicly. Religious
freedom is a constitutional right in both Nigeria and United States as it is recognized by the
constitutions of the two countries as a fundamental freedom. The research work is doctrinalbased
and it is motivated by the need to know the attitude of judges in both Nigeria and United
States of America towards religious freedom. The research is also propelled by the
constitutionality of freedom of religion in both countries, whether it is absolute or limited. It is
worth highlighting that judges, as human beings, could have deep-rooted religious convictions
that may influence their attitudes towards issue of religious freedom. Such attitude could be
controversial and problematic as it may sometimes, be contrary to the grain of constitutionality
and constitutionalism or the secular character of the country. A judge, in pursuit of his
ideological or personal religious values, may interpret the law to pander his ideological and
personal religious conviction, especially in US where the judges are constitutionally empowered
to fill in identified gaps in law. This is largely responsible for the sharp division in the U S
Supreme Court as justices are split along ideological and religious lines. While the
accomodationists hold the view that the relationship between the state and religion is inevitable,
the separationists maintain that the wall of separation between religion and the overall structure
of governance is high and impregnable and that it should not be broken by a slightest breach.
Though Nigerian judges may have deep-seated religious beliefs, but there are no indications that
they allow their religious views to play any significant role in the interpretation of law as it
relates to religious freedom. They are as good as constitutional purists as they interpret the law
as it is regardless of their personal religious views. It is however, well beyond dispute that in
both countries, the judges are unanimous on the limited nature of religious freedom. Though a
fundamental freedom protected by the constitution, the judges believed that it can be controlled
by the government to serve the interest of national security and stability. The Judges in both
countries also believed that religious ideologies, views and opinions are inviolable, but the
practice of those ideologies and views can be curtailed by the government in the interest of
public order and safety. In conclusion, judicial interpretation of freedom of religion if properly
handled can advance the course of national cohesion and understanding in a multi-religious and
heterogeneous country like Nigeria or U.S. where the fault line of religion, ethnicity and race are
exploited by unscrupulous individuals for personal gains.
Description
Keywords
Citation
BEING A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE SCHOOL OF POST GRADUATE, FACULTY OF LAW, NASARAWA STATE UNIVERSITY, KEFFI, IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENT FOR THE AWARD OF MASTERS DEGREE (LL.M) IN LAW
