COMPARATIVE STUDY OF THE ENFORCEMENT OF SOCIAL AND ECONOMIC RIGHTS IN NIGERIA, GHANA AND SOUTH AFRICA
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW, FACULTY OF LAW, NASARAWA STATE UNIVERSITY, KEFFI
DOI
Abstract
Before the Second World War, there was hardly any support for the protection of universal
human rights. However, the idea of fundamental rights and freedom received international
attention in the aftermath of the violations of human rights during the Second World War,
which led to the adoption of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) in 1948.
The Declaration provides for, and accords equal recognition to two sets of human rights: the
civil and political rights as well as the economic, social and cultural rights. The Declaration
was later transformed into legally binding obligations in two separate covenants to wit,
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and International Covenant on
Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR). These covenants, together with the UDHR,
constitute the International Bill of Rights. It is noteworthy that the United Nations (UN) and
the individual member states take the official position that these two sets of rights are
complementary, universal, indivisible, inter-dependent and inter-related. However, it has been
observed that, in practice, civil and political rights have for years received, both at the
international and national levels, much more prominence than socio-economic rights. This
attitude invariably affects the degree of seriousness given to the enforcement of socioeconomic
rights in various jurisdictions of the world. Using the doctrinal approach where both
primary and secondary sources are examined which include statutes, case-laws and other legal
sources, this dissertation sets out to carry a comparative study of the enforcement of SERs in
three selected jurisdictions, i.e Nigeria, Ghana and South Africa. The dissertation aims to
identify among others, the nature of economic and social rights in each of these jurisdictions
and the extent to which they are protected and enforced. Constitutional protection and judicial
attitude are the common indices used in comparatively assessing the jurisdictions chosen for
this research. The dissertation also traces the origins and historical evolution of human rights,
in general, and socio-economic rights in particular and also examined the legal and
institutional framework of socio-economic rights under international and regional
instruments. The findings of this dissertation among others, is that while South Africa
provides the most constitutionally conducive environment for the enforcement of SERs,
Ghana comes as second by virtue of the hybrid constitutional framework and the positive
attitude of Ghanaian courts towards the enforcement of socio-economic rights while Nigeria
is found to be lagging behind as a result of the non-justiciable character of SERs in Nigeria’s
Constitution as well as the weak judicial attitude towards their enforcement. The dissertation
also identifies some challenges to the enforcement of SERs in Africa which include
corruption and inept leadership which has taken the center stage in depriving its citizens from
the enjoyment of SERs. The dissertation advocates the recognition of SERs as enforceable
rights in Nigeria and Ghana which recommendation is in consonance with their obligations as
signatories to the ACHPR and ICESCR. The study also recommends the enactment of strict
sanctions which will serve as deterrent to public officials in order to curb the menace of
corruption and ensure that the resources of the state are harnessed for the benefit of citizens.
The dissertation concludes that a combination of constitutional strategies, political will and
virile civil society will go a long way in turning things around as far as SERs is concerned in
the three selected jurisdictions.
Description
Keywords
Citation
A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE SCHOOL OF POST GRADUATE STUDIES, NASARAWA STATE UNIVERSITY, KEFFI IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE AWARD OF THE DEGREE OF MASTERS OF LAW (LLM) IN CONSTITUTIONAL AND HUMAN RIGHTS LAW.
