CONTRIBUTION OF HYBRID/SPECIAL TRIBUNALS TO THE DEVELOPMENT OF INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL JUSTICE
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
FACULTY OF LAW NASARAWA STATE UNIVERSITY, KEFFI, NIGERIA
DOI
Abstract
In a transitional justice process, local trials often lack legitimacy because judicial
institutions are not always impartial and independent. Trials by purely international
tribunals such as ICTY, ICTR and ICC are always viewed with suspicion for want of
legitimacy. The trials are located outside of the theatres of conflict with result that the
victims lack tf ownership ” of the trials. The impact of the trials on the society concerned
is minimal. Hybrid tribunals have emerged as a response to the deficiencies of fully
domestic and fully international courts. They combine the best of the two worlds: the
purely domestic and purely international prosecution of crimes in transitional justice
situations. This feat is achieved in three core areas of legitimacy, capacity building and
norm penetration. The work assesses the contribution and role of the hybrid courts in
bridging the impunity gap under the jurisdictional framework of the ICC for reasons of
limited capacity of both domestic courts and ICC and as a guarantee for fairness in the
international criminal justice system. The study proceeds to investigate the reason behind
the establishment of the hybrid courts, their functions and the contribution they have
made to the development of international criminal justice. The study notes two major
approaches to legal research namely: the doctrinal and non-doctrinal approaches.
Doctrinal or library based research is the most common methodology employed by those
undertaking research in law. Therefore, this study adopts doctrinal approach relying on
both primary and secondary sources. The study finds that the model of hybrid tribunal
has developed not as a substitute for the ICC but as a supplemental mechanism of justice
in areas outside of the ICC’s reach and in situations where ICC involvement would not
be beneficial for variety of reasons. The study discovers that purely international
criminal tribunals have done virtually nothing in the area of capacity building of local
judicial infrastructure and norm penetration. Tripartite grounding of sociological
legitimacy, capacity building and norm penetration put the hybrid courts ahead of purely
international criminal tribunals in dispensation of international criminal justice. The
study recommends the hybrid model for the war-ravaged North-Eastern Nigeria where
Boko Haram terrorists have committed unimaginable atrocities against the people
leaving in their wake death and devastated infrastructure. After examining the emerging
literature on the subject which favours establishment of more hybrid courts and recent
developments in Central African Republic (CAR), South Sudan, DRC, Kosovo and Sri
Lanka where either a hybrid court has just been established or is about to be established,
the study concludes that hybrid courts have justified their establishment having
contributed immensely to the development of international criminal justice in a variety of
ways
Description
Keywords
Citation
BEING A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE SCHOOL OF POSTGRADUATE STUDIES, NASARAWA STATE UNIVERSITY, KEFFI IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE AWARD OF A MASTER OF LAWS (LL.M) DEGREE
